The debate over charcoal vs gas is one that has gone on forever it seems like. The one simple thing you need to know is that it is a matter of taste and convenience. To encompass the whole range of grills, add to this list electric grills and hardwood cooking as well.
The best way to think about this question is to remember that generally the more convenient a grill becomes the less really smoke flavor you are going to get. An electric grill is easiest to use but doesn't have that real fire flavor, while hardwood fires give you the best flavor but are the hardest work.
The authentic smoky, off the fire taste of grilled foods is strongest with the original heat source, wood. As you move to electric you find very little of this flavor left. In fact, many electric grills add virtually nothing to the taste of foods.
Which grill produces better flavor?
Because taste is so subjective and personal, the debate will probably continue regarding whether charcoal or gas grilling produces superior flavor. Multitudes of taste tests have demonstrated that most people cannot tell the difference. But then again some can.
Which grill lights easier?
Gas grills are a snap to light. You simply turn on the gas, push the igniter button, and adjust the control to high — in just 10 minutes or less you are ready to cook.
Despite the fact that many people would argue otherwise, charcoal grills are not difficult to light. The fact is, charcoal grills are extremely easy to light and take only about 30 minutes to reach a medium stage of heat.
Which grill looks better?
This one's a tie. With people spending more and more money to spruce up their backyards, you have dozens of attractive grills to choose from, whether cooking with charcoal or gas. Grills come in high-tech, contemporary, gleaming stainless steel or wonderful bright-colored porcelain enamel. Choose from bright red, cobalt blue, or even designer colors like teal. Even painted gas grills come in colors like hunter green or burgundy. Handsome carts or cabinets in stainless steel or wood finishes add to the sturdiness and beauty that can enhance your patio or deck.
Buying a grill that suits your style and needs is a little like buying a car, except, unfortunately, you can't take it out for a test drive. Table 1 is a straight-up comparison of some features of charcoal and gas grills.
The Verdict
Ultimately, any determination of what's best comes down to considerations of convenience, cost, flavor and practicality. If you have a tiny patio, a massive gas grill just won't work. Great grilling can be had over either gas or charcoal flames.
|
